What are MEN saying about infant circumcision

The worst thing is that it produces circumcisers. There is a segment of physicians who have the psychic compulsion to circumcise so they themselves do not feel genitally inferior or different

Could it be that the circumcised father is the one whose psyche is so disturbed that he suggests circumcision so his little son's genital status would not surpass his own?

Thomas J. Ritter, M.D.

Sex with a circumcised penis has been likened to 'trying to appreciate one of Goya's masterpieces by looking at a black and white photograph?'
Kenneth Purvis, M.D., Ph.D.

The same type of cultural astigmatism which prevented past generations from perceiving their actions as child abuse prevents contemporary Americans from perceiving or acknowledging the most widespread form of child abuse in society today; child mutilation through routine neonatal circumcision of males.
William E. Brigman
Circumcision as Child Abuse:
Legal-Constitutional Issues
University of Louisville
Journal of Family Law,

My preference, if I had the good fortune to have another son, would be to leave his little penis alone.
Benjamin Spock, M.D.
Baby and Child Care
in Redbook, p.53, April 1989

My first major loss was being severed forever from a sensitive part of my boy's body - my foreskin. This mutilation is an initiation into the warrior cult, which predates its medical and religious meanings and begins the wounding of our boys into manhood. We would benefit from better ways to treat our boys.
Shepherd Bliss - My War Story: A Child's Trauma
Journeyman
5242
Äänestä

Muut lukivat myös

Vastaukset 5

Vanhimmat

Taasko se Esinahkafilogia pääsi mieliaiheeseensa?

Äänestä
  • Childhood genital mutilations are anachronistic rituals inflicted on the helpless bodies of non-consenting children of both sexes.
    Hanny Lightfoot-Klein (personal correspondence) - author, Prisoners of Ritual: An Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, 1989
    When a child is subjected to intolerable, overwhelming pain, it conceptualizes mother as both participatory and responsible regardless of mother's intent. The perception of the infant of her culpability and willingness to have him harmed is indelibly emplaced. The consequences for impaired bonding are significant.
    Rima Laibow, M.D. - Circumcision and its Relationship to Attachment Impairment
    Syllabus of Abstracts Second International Symposium on Circumcision, April 30, 1991
    It is not easy to see evil in something that has the sanction of long tradition, but traditions can be bad or good. The represent inherited error as well as inherited truth.
    Archbishop Lang - United Kingdom
    Isn't it insulting to the average male's intelligence to think that surgery is preferable because he can't be trusted with washing his genitals when somehow he manages to brush his teeth, clean his ears and blow his nose?
    Louanne Cole, Ph.D. - Sex Matters Columnist Is Circumcision Correct for Newborn Boys?
    San Francisco Examiner, p.B7, August 11, 1993
    Circumcision simply counteracts excessive lust; for there is no doubt that (it) weakens the power of sexual excitement, and sometimes lessens the natural enjoyment.
    Moses Maimonides - Jewish Scholar (1135-1204 A.D.), The Guide of the Perplexed
    No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
    Article V, United Nations Declaration of Human Rights
    What's done to children, they will do to society.

    Äänestä

  • Other Voices kirjoitti:

    Childhood genital mutilations are anachronistic rituals inflicted on the helpless bodies of non-consenting children of both sexes.
    Hanny Lightfoot-Klein (personal correspondence) - author, Prisoners of Ritual: An Odyssey into Female Genital Circumcision in Africa, 1989
    When a child is subjected to intolerable, overwhelming pain, it conceptualizes mother as both participatory and responsible regardless of mother's intent. The perception of the infant of her culpability and willingness to have him harmed is indelibly emplaced. The consequences for impaired bonding are significant.
    Rima Laibow, M.D. - Circumcision and its Relationship to Attachment Impairment
    Syllabus of Abstracts Second International Symposium on Circumcision, April 30, 1991
    It is not easy to see evil in something that has the sanction of long tradition, but traditions can be bad or good. The represent inherited error as well as inherited truth.
    Archbishop Lang - United Kingdom
    Isn't it insulting to the average male's intelligence to think that surgery is preferable because he can't be trusted with washing his genitals when somehow he manages to brush his teeth, clean his ears and blow his nose?
    Louanne Cole, Ph.D. - Sex Matters Columnist Is Circumcision Correct for Newborn Boys?
    San Francisco Examiner, p.B7, August 11, 1993
    Circumcision simply counteracts excessive lust; for there is no doubt that (it) weakens the power of sexual excitement, and sometimes lessens the natural enjoyment.
    Moses Maimonides - Jewish Scholar (1135-1204 A.D.), The Guide of the Perplexed
    No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment.
    Article V, United Nations Declaration of Human Rights
    What's done to children, they will do to society.

    Miehelle ei ole ympärileikkauksesta muuta kuin
    hyötyä.

    Äänestä

  • Pakana(M) kirjoitti:

    Miehelle ei ole ympärileikkauksesta muuta kuin
    hyötyä.

    Recent Research on Male Genital Anatomy The
    published research of Dr. John Taylor
    demonstrates how circumcision destroys one-half
    of the skin and nervous system of the penis.

    Äänestä

  • Copyandpaste kirjoitti:

    Recent Research on Male Genital Anatomy The
    published research of Dr. John Taylor
    demonstrates how circumcision destroys one-half
    of the skin and nervous system of the penis.

    Seliseli.

    Äänestä

Kommentoi aloitusta


http://www.noharmm.org kirjoitti:

The worst thing is that it produces circumcisers. There is a segment of physicians who have the psychic compulsion to circumcise so they themselves do not feel genitally inferior or different

Could it be that the circumcised father is the one whose psyche is so disturbed that he suggests circumcision so his little son's genital status would not surpass his own?

Thomas J. Ritter, M.D.

Sex with a circumcised penis has been likened to 'trying to appreciate one of Goya's masterpieces by looking at a black and white photograph?'
Kenneth Purvis, M.D., Ph.D.

The same type of cultural astigmatism which prevented past generations from perceiving their actions as child abuse prevents contemporary Americans from perceiving or acknowledging the most widespread form of child abuse in society today; child mutilation through routine neonatal circumcision of males.
William E. Brigman
Circumcision as Child Abuse:
Legal-Constitutional Issues
University of Louisville
Journal of Family Law,

My preference, if I had the good fortune to have another son, would be to leave his little penis alone.
Benjamin Spock, M.D.
Baby and Child Care
in Redbook, p.53, April 1989

My first major loss was being severed forever from a sensitive part of my boy's body - my foreskin. This mutilation is an initiation into the warrior cult, which predates its medical and religious meanings and begins the wounding of our boys into manhood. We would benefit from better ways to treat our boys.
Shepherd Bliss - My War Story: A Child's Trauma
Journeyman

Anonyymi
5000

Ilmoita asiaton sisältö

  • Sisältää materiaalia, joka on loukkaavaa, herjaavaa, rasistista, uhkailevaa tai ahdistelevaa.

  • Materiaali sisältää nimiä, yhteystietoja tai muita henkilökohtaisia tietoja. Julkisuuden henkilöistä, julkisissa viroissa toimivista ihmisistä sekä yritysten vastuuhenkilöistä saa keskustella työhön liittyen. Myös yksityiselämään liittyvistä asioista voi keskustella siltä osin, kuin niistä on julkisesti kerrottu.

  • Sisältää lapsille haitallista tai heiltä kiellettyä materiaalia. Seksuaalinen sisältö on sallittua aiheeseen tarkoitetuilla palstoilla, joiden ikäraja on 18 vuotta.

  • Lainvastaista sisältöä voi olla mm. yksityiselämää loukkaavan tiedon levitys, kiihottaminen kansanryhmää vastaan, laiton uhkaaminen, alaikäisiin liittyvä seksuaalinen sisältö/grooming, petokset, identiteettivarkaudet, kunnianloukkaukset ja tekijänoikeusrikkomukset.

  • Sisältö ei liity palstan tai keskusteluketjun aiheeseen.

  • Viesti ei ole suomea tai ruotsia (pl. International Forums), se sisältää mainontaa, se sisältää tekijänoikeuksin suojattua materiaalia, se on massapostitus tai jokin muu syy.

Jaa keskustelu