44.
Pressure in oil / gas wells indicate the recent origin of the oil and gas.
If they were many millions of years old we would expect the pressures to equilibrate, even in low permeability rocks. “Experts in petroleum prospecting note the impossibility of creating an effective model given long and slow oil generation over millions of years (Petukhov, 2004).
In their opinion, if models demand the standard multimillion-years geochronological scale, the best exploration strategy is to drill wells on a random grid.” Lalomov, A.V., 2007. Mineral deposits as an example of geological rates. CRSQ 44(1):64–66.
--------
http://www.answersincreation.org/argument/G342_creation_science.htm
Response:
1.Kent assumes the earth is young and leaky. If true, the pressures we see would never have built up in the first place
2.The high pressures of the reservoirs show that the rocks are impermeable, and able to withstand the pressures over long periods of time.
3.The existence of pressure has nothing to do with the age of the rocks or the oil. Oil which is millions of years old could have just migrated into the reservoir where it is found
http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/hovind/howgood-yea2.html#proof18
Oil and gas do a lot of migrating, and the oil accumulated in a given reservoir may have recently migrated there from another reservoir. Thus, a given pool of oil may or may not have been there for millions and millions of years. A recent geological shift in the rocks might also increase the leakage of the primary oil pool, which had been hitherto sealed for millions of years. Thus, the mere existence of leaky trapping rocks does not prove that a pool of oil and gas was recently created.
Thus, the primary migration of oil from its place of origin will take far longer than the mere 6000 years or so creationists allow for the age of the earth. Creationists have tried to dance around that figure by quoting special cases of secondary migration or by simple smoke screen tactics, but the problem remains (Strahler, 1987, pp.237-238).
Pressure in oil / gas wells indicate the recent origin of the oil and gas.
If they were many millions of years old we would expect the pressures to equilibrate, even in low permeability rocks. “Experts in petroleum prospecting note the impossibility of creating an effective model given long and slow oil generation over millions of years (Petukhov, 2004).
In their opinion, if models demand the standard multimillion-years geochronological scale, the best exploration strategy is to drill wells on a random grid.” Lalomov, A.V., 2007. Mineral deposits as an example of geological rates. CRSQ 44(1):64–66.
--------
http://www.answersincreation.org/argument/G342_creation_science.htm
Response:
1.Kent assumes the earth is young and leaky. If true, the pressures we see would never have built up in the first place
2.The high pressures of the reservoirs show that the rocks are impermeable, and able to withstand the pressures over long periods of time.
3.The existence of pressure has nothing to do with the age of the rocks or the oil. Oil which is millions of years old could have just migrated into the reservoir where it is found
http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/hovind/howgood-yea2.html#proof18
Oil and gas do a lot of migrating, and the oil accumulated in a given reservoir may have recently migrated there from another reservoir. Thus, a given pool of oil may or may not have been there for millions and millions of years. A recent geological shift in the rocks might also increase the leakage of the primary oil pool, which had been hitherto sealed for millions of years. Thus, the mere existence of leaky trapping rocks does not prove that a pool of oil and gas was recently created.
Thus, the primary migration of oil from its place of origin will take far longer than the mere 6000 years or so creationists allow for the age of the earth. Creationists have tried to dance around that figure by quoting special cases of secondary migration or by simple smoke screen tactics, but the problem remains (Strahler, 1987, pp.237-238).
Vastaukset
Vanhimmat
Ei vielä vastauksia
Aloittaja odottaa vastauksia. Kerro oma näkemyksesi ensimmäisenä.