Siinä vastataan Bacmanin kyselyyn McKitrickistä, eli kuitataan lätkämailan paljastajan väitteet sillä, että Kitrickillä on muistinmenetys.
"Dear Martti Backman,
I was not informed about McIntyres new findings. Thank you for notification.
But Keith Briffa asked me for some explanations because he is being
criticized by somebody for his using of recent data and some anonymous
asked me for raw data.
Unfortunately, Im full out with urgent work during nearest three
weeks and cant comment in details all the accusations (especially
because writing in English is to hard for me, excuse).
I had a look to McIntyres post and can superficially comment some
sentence.
>A few days ago, I became aware that the long-sought Yamal measurement
>data url had materialized at Briffa's website - after many years of
>effort on my part and nearly 10 years after its original use in Briffa
>(2000).
Steve has an amnesia. I had sent him these data at FebruaryREDACTEDon
his demand.
>The following graphic (H and S Figure 6) shows the core count by year
>for the 241 series selected into the H and S chronology: Figure 2.
>Series Counts in H and S Chronology 2002
(fig 6 from our paper)
Replication is shown on the next figure in our paper (fig. 7). Fig. 6
total number of dated subfossil samples (without living trees)
total number of dated samles was more than 241 at that time.
Low number of used for reconstruction subfossil series is explained by
standardization method. We selected the longest series. The same
concerns to living trees. It is not much old living trees in this area
(in contrast to Polar Urals), therefore we used only 17 (not 12).
At that time we had close collaboration and I had sent to Keith Briffa
these raw data.
As to reliability of recent increase in tree growth we have updated
our data using many additional subfossil and living trees and using
RCS-method. I.e. we used not only long series, therefore many (120)
living trees have been used. Finally, we have almost the Briffas
result. These results not published yet. Im going to prepare paper at
the end of this beginning next year. Some preliminary data you can
find in some kind of report in Russian
[1]
"Dear Martti Backman,
I was not informed about McIntyres new findings. Thank you for notification.
But Keith Briffa asked me for some explanations because he is being
criticized by somebody for his using of recent data and some anonymous
asked me for raw data.
Unfortunately, Im full out with urgent work during nearest three
weeks and cant comment in details all the accusations (especially
because writing in English is to hard for me, excuse).
I had a look to McIntyres post and can superficially comment some
sentence.
>A few days ago, I became aware that the long-sought Yamal measurement
>data url had materialized at Briffa's website - after many years of
>effort on my part and nearly 10 years after its original use in Briffa
>(2000).
Steve has an amnesia. I had sent him these data at FebruaryREDACTEDon
his demand.
>The following graphic (H and S Figure 6) shows the core count by year
>for the 241 series selected into the H and S chronology: Figure 2.
>Series Counts in H and S Chronology 2002
(fig 6 from our paper)
Replication is shown on the next figure in our paper (fig. 7). Fig. 6
total number of dated subfossil samples (without living trees)
total number of dated samles was more than 241 at that time.
Low number of used for reconstruction subfossil series is explained by
standardization method. We selected the longest series. The same
concerns to living trees. It is not much old living trees in this area
(in contrast to Polar Urals), therefore we used only 17 (not 12).
At that time we had close collaboration and I had sent to Keith Briffa
these raw data.
As to reliability of recent increase in tree growth we have updated
our data using many additional subfossil and living trees and using
RCS-method. I.e. we used not only long series, therefore many (120)
living trees have been used. Finally, we have almost the Briffas
result. These results not published yet. Im going to prepare paper at
the end of this beginning next year. Some preliminary data you can
find in some kind of report in Russian
[1]
Vastaukset 2
Vanhimmat
Mull tuli virhe, Steve on tietysti Steve McIntyre, nuo skotit mäkkäreineen.
Ja koko bacmannnia ketju #4981