Onko Jacques Derrida kuollut? Milloin?
Jacques Derrida
Tiedoton
2213
0Äänestä
Muut lukivat myös
Odottaa vastausta
Näihin keskusteluihin ei ole vielä vastattu. Ole ensimmäinen.
Turvaa tilisi vahvistamalla puhelinnumerosi. Voit silloin palauttaa unohtuneen salasanan tekstiviestillä.
Näihin keskusteluihin ei ole vielä vastattu. Ole ensimmäinen.
Vastaukset 2
Vanhimmat
Lehtijuttu
http://www.mtv3.fi/uutiset/ulkomaat/ulkomaat.shtml?2004/10/321008
Löytyi Googlen avulla haulla:
Jacques Derrida kuollut
En ole koskaan oikein ymmärtänyt Derridan ajattelua, onko joku onnistunut paremmin?
Mielenkiintoinen näkökanta:
The inventor of “deconstruction”—an ill-defined habit of dismantling texts by revealing their assumptions and contradictions—was indeed, and unfortunately, one of the most cited modern scholars in the humanities.
[...]
It is not that Mr Derrida's views, or his arguments for them, were unusually contentious. There were no arguments, nor really any views either. He would have been the first to admit this. He not only contradicted himself, over and over again, but vehemently resisted any attempt to clarify his ideas. “A critique of what I do”, he said, “is indeed impossible.”
Subjected to his weak puns (“logical phallusies” was a famous example), bombastic rhetoric and illogical ramblings, an open-minded reader might suspect Mr Derrida of charlatanism. That would be going too far, however. He was a sincere and learned man, if a confused one, who offered some academics and students just what they were looking for.
[...]
Armed with an impenetrable new vocabulary, and without having to master any rigorous thought, they could masquerade as social, political and philosophical critics. Mr Derrida always denied any responsibility for the undisciplined nihilism of his imitators, who gave the strong impression that deconstructionism had somehow succeeded in undermining, or even in refuting, the notion of objective truth. But his work could not easily be interpreted in any other way.
http://foreigndispatches.typepad.com/dispatches/2004/10/the_economist_o.html